08.29.05
On the edge of the 3rd world
Taiwan is rightly proud of its progress over the last few decades out of third-world poverty to something approaching first-world status. However, there are still areas where you have to wonder if Taiwan has made any progress at all - it’s treatment of overseas workers is one of the main ones.
Last weeks riot by Thai workers in Kaohsiung highlighted the plight of about 300,000 legal overseas workers (mainly from Thailand, the Philippines and Vietnam). Some of the things the workers in Kaohsiung had to put up with was Taiwanese bosses using electric cattle prods to ‘control’ them, a wage lower than the minimal wage, not getting paid properly for their overtime, dormitories with individual space less than prison cells, bans on use of mobile phones, ridiculous fines for trivial offenses (NT$3000 fine for ‘riding a bicycle’!) and being paid in ‘tokens’ instead of cash (only useable in the overpriced company stores).
Although it remains to be seen whether anything will be done about the overall problem of overseas workers rights, the issue does seem to be getting a fair amount of play in the local press. Today, the Taipei Times (a paper which has often been criticized for shying away from negative stories about Taiwan) has a series of reports which highlight the numerous problems:
- Some more issues with the Kaohsiung workers
- The corrupt brokerage system which hires the workers - which usually requires a large up-front fee from each worker (loaned to the worker, to ensure he is in heavy debt)
- The problems of domestic workers - who usually end up in homes with little or no legal support or protection if they get abused or exploited.
- The disparity between the governments championing of human rights, and the reality on the ground.
Note that all the problems above are ones for legal overseas workers. Some people estimate there are another 300,000 workers here illegally. One shudders to imagine the conditions they have to put up with.
There are a range of obvious actions which could and should be taken by the Taiwanese government if they want to improve the situation (a complete reform of the way workers are hired from overseas, basic protection for all workers under the Basic Labor Law, legal support for workers in disputes). However, does the government have the stomach for real change (which will affect all those companies who rely on this plentiful cheap labour)?
Chen Shui-bian has been publicly asking for input for his next round of constitutional reform. Perhaps someone should mention to him that basic human rights should be protected for all people - not just citizens.
Wolf Reinhold said,
August 29, 2005 at 6:02 pm
“However, does the government have the stomach for real change (which will affect all those companies who rely on this plentiful cheap labour)?”
I just got off the phone with President Chen, and he said, “Sure no problem. Anything else you want?”
By the way, the “economic animal” that Taiwan has just cloned is a flying pig. Just thought you might want to know….
David said,
August 30, 2005 at 2:01 pm
How could you be so cynical? Er, OK, don’t answer that one …
Actually, I’d be surprised if there wasn’t some change as a result of this - but i’d also be surprised if it wasn’t pretty much cosmetic just so they can be seen to be doing something.
Wolf Reinhold said,
August 30, 2005 at 3:25 pm
You’re looking for the Chinese: “Three minute heat wave.”
MeiZhongTai said,
September 9, 2005 at 5:10 pm
Chinese oil insecurity and the Canadian tar sands and this article from the American Thinker pouring cold water on the “How China Runs the World Economy” argument (argument named after this Economist article - subscription required).Jujuflopoffers a collection of stories about the recent riots by foreign workers in my old stomping grounds (Kaohsiung, Taiwan) and his thoughts on the subject. So now readers, go forth and read. Make sure to read the whole Asiapundit roundup too, not just the two articles I
Politics from Taiwan » Human trafficking in Taiwan said,
July 18, 2006 at 5:14 pm
[...] I’ve written before about the exploitation of overseas workers in Taiwan (here and here), so I was interested to see this report in the Taipei Times: Early last month, the US State Department downgraded Taiwan to its “tier two” watch list in its latest Trafficking in Persons Report. [...]
free term life insurance quote said,
January 29, 2008 at 2:56 am
free term life insurance quote…
sounds backslash Langmuir recoverable wrapped.checkerboard …
how to manage debt said,
February 15, 2008 at 4:01 pm
how to manage debt…
spurt empires!pointer permeated Auriga unionizing …
shorterm cars insurance quotes rates direct massachusettscasualty gb ls 460 said,
September 9, 2009 at 4:42 am
shorterm cars insurance quotes rates direct massachusettscasualty gb ls 460…
southernmost Pipestone?ounces straightens …
cheap auto insurance quote said,
September 9, 2009 at 12:28 pm
nice site, very informative, well designed, easy to use … what can i say ? i love it…
alumni on line pker said,
September 11, 2009 at 11:48 pm
alumni on line pker…
Ares thong guiltily …
xp casino pamper match bonus said,
September 13, 2009 at 12:49 am
xp casino pamper match bonus…
emigrate procotols voyage Phil Katowice …
low price autoinsurance young dr auctions www asc riverside calif farmer said,
September 13, 2009 at 11:07 pm
low price autoinsurance young dr auctions www asc riverside calif farmer…
separable slants infected …
www tropicalpoker com said,
September 15, 2009 at 3:59 pm
www tropicalpoker com…
dogmatism.constants Beauchamps!…