10.12.05
Bloody politicians
Yesterday’s fights in the Legislature plumbed new depths of moronic and loutish behaviour with at least two legislators ending up in hospital.
Pan-green lawmakers resorted to violence for the second time in an attempt to block the bill yesterday. The first time was two weeks ago when they paralyzed a session by storming the speaker’s podium.
Kuomintang and People First Party lawmakers labeled the pan-green alliance as “violent parties,” while the Democratic Progressive Party and Taiwan Solidarity Union slammed their rivals as the “violent majority.”
KMT lawmaker Chang Sho-wen was struck in his left eye with his cellular phone and blood gushed from his face. He accused DPP lawmaker Lee Ming-hsien (李明憲) of attacking him.
Meanwhile Lee, who was injured on his lips, knees, and nose, accused Chang of insulting him, saying he hit Chang in self-defense. Both lawmakers were sent to the hospital for treatment.
ESWN and Wandering to Tamshui have already done a good job of covering the punch-ups. Suffice to say that it rated somewhere between a schoolground fight and a barroom brawl. A few issues are worth noting about this though:
- The fight was about whether the members of a media watchdog body should be assigned by the Executive Yuan or the Legislative Yuan. Could you get worked up about such a detail enough to draw blood?
- Legislative Speaker Wang Jin-pyng (王金平) failed to act on his threat to call in the police:
Later in the day, Wang said he did not call the police when a second attempt was made to storm the podium since legislative staff and Non-Partisan Solidarity Union lawmakers helped him stop pan-green lawmakers from retaking it. The attempt was made as lawmakers were reviewing the first article of the NCC.
In other words, because the blues won the fight, there was no need for the police. How daft is that? It wouldn’t be hard to say that anyone who tried to use physical force to get onto the podium would be evicted and possibly arrested by the police. Sitting and watching the developing fight and doing nothing is very weak leadership of the legislature. It’s pretty clear to me the legislature needs some sort of discipline, and Wang is not providing it.
- The day before this (wholly predictable) fight, the leaders of the two main parties were sitting next to each other chatting about the weather at the National Day celebrations. Why did they not discuss how to restrain their legislators? Waiting for a fight to break out and then blaming the other side is pathetic leadership by both DPP Chairman Su Tseng-chang (蘇貞昌) and KMT Chairman Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九)
So although it’s generally junior party members acting like drunken idiots and doing the actual fighting, the fact that senior politicians are providing no sensible leadership makes them just as guilty as their subordinates.
Wolf Reinhold said,
October 12, 2005 at 7:52 pm
Dressing up like kung fu hipsters and wearing military fatigues (you forgot the woman legislator with her helmet and shield) and the placards and shouting and smacking each other………..don’t they know the impact this has on the international community? Moreover, China should be broadcasting all the sessions live with a big logo at the top saying “Taiwan Provincial Democracy at Work.” The “pan-blue alliance” is making a very good case for the US to renounce helping Taiwan in time of need (”They aren’t worth it”) and helping China show its people that democracy leads to this. I point the finger at the blues mostly (although the greens should be castrated) because were it not for them introducing radically partisan bills (the NCC made up of the legislative ratio which means trouble), or bills that are unconstitutional (319 “truth” commission), or fail to allow needed legislation to pass (flood-control bill) the greens would not have to resort to PFP black-shirt tactics.
It's Not Democracy, It's A Conspiracy! said,
October 29, 2005 at 6:11 pm
in the legislature. This means that if the pan-blues control the legislature, they also control the NCC. This in turn means that their control of the media will only become more extreme. Why didn’t the DPP talk about this before, especially in thebloody runup to this legislative mess? Why haven’t they talked about it every day since they’ve known about such things? Are they, like so many Taiwanese, just suicidal? There isn’t even a hint of self-preservational instinct in this sort of behavior.
Politics from Taiwan » Outbreak of sanity in the legislature said,
March 8, 2006 at 12:34 pm
[...] Yesterday was the first meeting of the Procedure Committee for the next session of the Legislature. Given the recent shouting matches over the NUC, I would have bet good money on this descending into arguments, pushing, shouting and possibly (as before) bloodshed. If fact, it was one of the least confrontational meetings in years. [...]
Hammerswing75 said,
March 11, 2006 at 2:41 am
DPP lawmaker Lee Ming-hsien (李明憲) of attacking him. Meanwhile Lee, who was injured on his lips, knees, and nose, accused Chang of insulting him, saying he hit Chang in self-defense. Both lawmakers were sent to the hospital for treatment. (link) This isn’t an isolate incident by any means, (obviously Taiwanese legislators are serious about consistent entertainment.) A particularly funny episode occurred in 2004 when they started a food fight.
The View from Taiwan said,
March 12, 2006 at 1:20 pm
Yesterday was the first meeting of the Procedure Committee for the next session of the Legislature. Given the recent shouting matches over the NUC, I would have bet good money on this descending into arguments, pushing, shouting and possibly (as before) bloodshed. If fact, it was one of the least confrontational meetings in years. It seems that someone (Premier Su?) has decided that proposing bills with zero chance of progress is not the way to go and has opened up the
alayne said,
December 16, 2006 at 10:31 am
You should post the achievements, goals, objectives and contributions of the politicians in taiwan.
hard money application no documentation on contruction loans said,
December 24, 2007 at 10:00 pm
hard money application no documentation on contruction loans…
twill synchronized.following brows?…
halloween bingo cards for kindergarten said,
February 3, 2008 at 11:19 pm
halloween bingo cards for kindergarten…
divisive hooted midday …
check credit personal said,
February 15, 2008 at 3:45 pm
check credit personal…
compassion!aggravate cartography …
cheap online car insurance uk said,
February 17, 2008 at 9:30 pm
cheap online car insurance uk…
percentages surrendered!flicker stairways hermetic:boil …
login said,
September 11, 2009 at 8:59 am
Keep it up (like I do :-)) Great site - loved the bit about yourselves.
senior driveinsurance coverage utahworkerscompensationfund in hampton virginia isuzu i 290 said,
September 13, 2009 at 11:11 pm
senior driveinsurance coverage utahworkerscompensationfund in hampton virginia isuzu i 290…
Redhook!sulfur hardcopy:grassers integrated Nielsen?…